First: Read the Letter Carefully
You are not going to be left without coverage. If you do nothing, you'll be enrolled in Original Medicare on January 1 — but with no prescription drug plan, and that gap can lead to a Part D late enrollment penalty.
Here's what to do, in order.
Plans end in several different ways, and the difference affects your options.
- The plan isn't being renewed — the insurer is discontinuing it entirely.
- The plan is leaving your county — it continues elsewhere but no longer serves where you live.
- The plan is being consolidated — members are moved into another plan from the same company. This one is easy to miss, because it can read like a routine notice.
That last case matters most. If you're being moved automatically, you are not required to accept the new plan, and the plan you're moved into may have different doctors, a different drug list, and different costs. Being moved is not the same as being matched.
Keep the letter. If your plan is ending rather than being merged into another plan from the same company, the letter is usually your proof of a special enrollment right and, in many cases, a Medigap guaranteed issue right. Put it somewhere you'll find it in January.
The Three Dates
October 15 – December 7. Annual Enrollment. You can join a different Medicare Advantage plan, or return to Original Medicare and add a drug plan. Whatever you choose takes effect January 1.
January 1. Your old plan ends. Your new coverage begins — or, if you've done nothing, Original Medicare begins without drug coverage.
December 8 – the last day of February. A special enrollment period for people whose plan wasn't renewed. This is your safety net, and it's a real one. But coverage from a choice made in January starts later than January 1, which can leave a gap in the meantime.
Use the December 7 deadline. Treat the February window as the backup it is.
Your Two Real Options
Option 1: Another Medicare Advantage Plan
You stay in the Medicare Advantage system with a different plan. Choosing one during Annual Enrollment means coverage starts January 1 with no gap.
Option 2: Original Medicare Plus a Drug Plan, and Possibly a Medigap Policy
You return to Original Medicare, add a stand-alone Part D drug plan, and may add a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) policy to cover what Original Medicare doesn't.
This path has a feature that most people in your situation don't know about, and it's the most valuable thing in this article.
The Medigap Right You May Not Know You Have
Normally, buying a Medigap policy after your initial enrollment window means answering health questions, and an insurer can turn you down or charge you more.
When your Medicare Advantage plan leaves Medicare or stops serving your area, you get a guaranteed issue right. That means an insurer must sell you certain Medigap policies regardless of your health history.
The details that matter:
- Which policies: Medigap Plan A, B, C, D, F, G, K or L, from any company selling them in your state. Plans C and F are generally not available to people who became eligible for Medicare on or after January 1, 2020. Wisconsin doesn't use these lettered plans; its Medigap policies are built on a state-mandated Basic Plan with optional riders (see our Wisconsin Medicare Supplement page).
- The window: you can apply as early as 60 calendar days before your Medicare Advantage coverage ends, and no later than 63 calendar days after it ends.
- The condition: this right applies only if you move to Original Medicare. Joining another Medicare Advantage plan instead means you don't use it.
If you've been wanting to leave Medicare Advantage — because of networks, referrals, or prior authorization — and have been told your health history would make a Medigap policy hard to get, this is the window where that obstacle is removed. It does not come around again on its own.
Apply before your coverage ends rather than after. Waiting until January to start the paperwork puts you up against a 63-day clock during the busiest time of year.
The Gap That Creates a Lifelong Penalty
This is the one that costs people money for the rest of their lives, and it's entirely avoidable.
If you go 63 days or more without creditable prescription drug coverage, you can be charged a Part D late enrollment penalty. "Creditable" means coverage at least as good as standard Part D.
How the penalty works:
- It adds a percentage of the national base beneficiary premium for each month you went without.
- It's added to your monthly premium for as long as you have Medicare drug coverage, even if you later switch plans.
- The amount changes each year as Medicare's base premium changes.
Here's where the trap is. Most Medicare Advantage plans include drug coverage. If your plan ends and you default into Original Medicare without adding a Part D plan, the clock starts — and many people don't realize they've lost drug coverage until they try to fill a prescription.
If you take no other action this year, take this one: make sure you have drug coverage in place on January 1.
How to Compare Replacements
Check these four things, in this order. Premium belongs last, not first.
- Your doctors. Look up each one individually in the new plan's directory, and then call the office to confirm. Directories go out of date, and "accepting Medicare" is not the same as "in network for this plan."
- Your hospital and specialists. Particularly if you're in treatment for something, or have a procedure scheduled for early next year.
- Your prescriptions. Enter every medication, with dosage, into the Medicare Plan Finder at medicare.gov/plan-compare. A drug that's covered on one plan may not be on another, or may sit on a more expensive tier.
- Your pharmacy. Preferred pharmacy networks change what you pay. The same plan can cost noticeably more at the wrong counter.
Then compare premiums, deductibles and out-of-pocket maximums. A plan that's cheaper monthly but drops your oncologist isn't cheaper.
If You're in Treatment Right Now
Continuity of care deserves its own look. Before choosing, ask the new plan directly whether an in-progress course of treatment, a scheduled surgery, or an existing prior authorization carries over. Get the answer in writing if you can, and note the date and the name of the person you spoke with.
Where to Get Help
You don't have to figure this out alone, and you don't have to talk to a salesperson to get answers.
1-800-MEDICARE (1-800-633-4227) is available 24 hours a day, 7 days a week.
Your State Health Insurance Assistance Program (SHIP) offers unbiased Medicare counseling. Counselors don't sell anything and aren't paid commissions. Wisconsin's program can walk through your specific plan options with you. In Wisconsin, you can reach it through the Wisconsin Medigap Helpline at 1-800-242-1060, run by the Wisconsin Board on Aging and Long Term Care as part of Wisconsin's SHIP.
Medicare Plan Finder at medicare.gov/plan-compare lets you enter your drugs and pharmacy and compare what's available where you live.
Questions About Your Situation?
Merit Protection Group is an independent insurance agency in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin, licensed in Wisconsin, Arizona and Colorado. If you've gotten one of these letters and have questions about what the options mean, we're glad to help.
We'll also tell you plainly when the right move is to call SHIP or 1-800-MEDICARE instead. Unbiased counseling exists, and it's good.
Read more about what to review during annual enrollment, explore our Medicare page, or contact us with questions. No pressure, and no obligation.
