Start With the Document You Probably Set Aside
Most people skip it. Their current plan works well enough, the mail is overwhelming, and nothing appears to be wrong. The trouble is that plans change even when your health doesn't, and the changes arrive quietly in a document most people never open.
Here's what's worth reviewing, and a few things specific to Wisconsin that national advice gets wrong.
If you're in a Medicare Advantage or Part D plan, your insurer sent you an Annual Notice of Change in late September. It's the most useful piece of Medicare mail you'll get all year, and it's the one most likely to end up in a pile.
Find it and check four things:
- Premium and deductible changes for next year
- Drug list changes: whether your medications are still covered and on the same tier
- Network changes: whether your doctors, clinic, and preferred pharmacy are still in network
- Benefit changes: copays for visits, and any adjustments to extras like dental or vision
If you can't find it, call your plan and ask them to send another copy, or look for it in your online member account.
What You Can Actually Change Right Now
During October 15 to December 7, you can:
- Switch from Original Medicare to a Medicare Advantage plan
- Switch from a Medicare Advantage plan back to Original Medicare
- Change from one Medicare Advantage plan to another
- Join, switch, or drop a Part D prescription drug plan
If you miss this window and you're in a Medicare Advantage plan, there's a second chance: from January 1 to March 31, you can switch to a different Medicare Advantage plan or return to Original Medicare. That window doesn't allow Part D changes on their own if you're in Original Medicare.
The Wisconsin Catch: Medigap Doesn't Work Like the Rest
Here's where national advice misleads Wisconsin residents, and it comes up every fall.
Annual enrollment is not an open season for Medicare Supplement coverage. Leaving a Medicare Advantage plan during these weeks doesn't guarantee you can buy a supplement to replace it. Outside your original six-month Medigap window or a specific guaranteed issue situation, insurers can review your health history and decline your application.
Wisconsin adds two wrinkles worth knowing:
We don't use lettered plans. Wisconsin is one of three states with a federal waiver to standardize its own Medigap coverage. Every policy starts from a state-mandated Basic Plan, and you add optional riders for things like the Part A deductible, Part B excess charges, or foreign travel emergency care. If someone tells you to "switch to Plan G," that plan isn't sold here.
Riders are generally added at purchase. Adding one later often means health underwriting, and it can be turned down. So a supplement policy bought in a hurry during December, without the riders you'll eventually want, can lock in a gap that's hard to close afterward.
The practical advice: if you're considering leaving Medicare Advantage for Original Medicare plus a supplement, find out whether you can actually get the supplement coverage you want before you drop your current plan. Not after.
Review Your Prescriptions, Not Just Your Premium
Drug coverage is where most money is won or lost, and it changes every year even when your prescriptions don't.
Make a list of every medication with its exact dose, then check each one against your plan's drug list for next year. Look at:
- Whether the drug is still covered at all
- Which tier it's on, since tier changes alter your cost even when coverage continues
- Whether prior authorization or quantity limits were added
- Whether your pharmacy is still preferred, since the same drug can cost different amounts at different pharmacies under the same plan
A plan with a higher premium can cost you less overall if it covers your medications better. Compare total yearly cost, not the monthly premium.
Questions Worth Asking Yourself
- Did I see a specialist this year who isn't in my plan's network?
- Did I get a bill that surprised me?
- Am I traveling more, or spending part of the year out of state?
- Did I start a new medication?
- Has my primary care clinic changed which plans it accepts?
A yes to any of these is a reason to look closely this year rather than letting the plan renew by default.
What Not to Let Decide for You
Between now and December, the advertising gets loud. A single advertised benefit is a poor reason to change plans. Extra dental or vision coverage can be genuinely useful, but check the yearly limits, which services are actually covered, and which providers accept it before it influences your decision.
The coverage that matters most is still the coverage for doctors, hospitals, and prescriptions.
Questions About Annual Enrollment?
Merit Protection Group is an independent agency in Wauwatosa. We answer Wisconsin residents' questions about Medicare coverage, with no pressure and no obligation. If you have questions about what to look for in your Annual Notice of Change, contact us or learn more about our Medicare services.
Newer to Medicare? Our guide on turning 65 in Wisconsin covers first-time enrollment.
If your Medicare Advantage plan is ending, read what to do when a Medicare Advantage plan ends.
