Merit Protection Group

Can Life Insurance Deny a Claim for Something You Left Off the Application?

Yes, it can happen. During the life insurance contestability period, usually the first two years a policy is in force, an insurer can go back and compare your application answers with your real history if a claim comes in. If it finds something important that was missing or wrong, it may reduce the payout or cancel the policy and refund the premiums instead of paying the full benefit. The good news is that this is easy to avoid once you know how it works. This guide comes from Merit Protection Group, an independent insurance agency, and it is general education about insurance, not legal advice.

Two young children sharing a swing in a sunny backyard

What is the life insurance contestability period?

Almost every individual life insurance policy has a contestability period. It usually covers the first two years after the policy is issued. During that window, the insurer can look more closely at a claim and check whether the answers on the application were complete and accurate.

Wisconsin law is a good example. Under Wis. Stat. § 632.46, an individual life insurance policy generally can't be contested after it has been in force for two years from the date of issue during the insured person's lifetime, with exceptions such as unpaid premiums and a misstated age. Most states use a similar two-year rule, but the exact wording lives in your policy and your state's law, so read the "incontestability" section of your own contract.

The contestability period is not a trap and it does not mean claims in the first two years are denied. Most early claims are paid. It simply gives the insurer a window to confirm that the policy was issued on accurate information.

What do insurers check when you apply and when a claim is filed?

With your written permission, insurers use outside records both during underwriting and when they review an early claim. Common sources include:

  • Prescription history from pharmacy databases
  • Medical records from your doctors and hospitals
  • Prior insurance applications shared through industry databases such as the Medical Information Bureau
  • Motor vehicle records, including tickets, accidents and DUIs

So a detail you forgot is often already on file somewhere. The real question is whether it would have changed the insurer's decision.

What kind of missing detail actually matters?

Insurers care about information that is material, meaning it would have changed whether they approved the application or what they charged for it. These are the details people overlook most often:

Easy to overlookWhy it matters to an insurer
Vaping, cigars, chewing tobacco or nicotine gumAny nicotine use usually counts as tobacco use, which changes the rate class
Scuba diving, skydiving, climbing, racing or flying a private planeHigher-risk hobbies can change the rate or add an exclusion
A prescription you no longer takeIt points to a diagnosis the underwriter would have asked about
A long trip or travel to certain countriesSome destinations change how an application is reviewed
A recent DUI, suspended license or several moving violationsDriving history is part of the risk picture

A small slip that would not have changed anything usually doesn't cause a problem. Under Wisconsin's statute, a misstated age or sex is handled by adjusting the benefit to what the premiums paid would have bought at the correct age, not by denying the claim.

What happens if an insurer finds a problem during the contestability period?

If a claim is filed in the first two years, the insurer may request records and take longer to review it. If the review finds that an important answer was wrong, the possible outcomes generally include:

  • Paying the claim in full, when the detail would not have changed the decision
  • Adjusting the benefit, for example when age was misstated
  • Rescinding the policy, which means treating it as if it never existed and refunding the premiums instead of paying the death benefit

Rescission is the outcome families fear most, and it is the one that complete, honest answers protect against. Rules on what an insurer must show differ by state and by situation, so a family facing a disputed claim should read the denial letter carefully and consider talking with an attorney.

Applying soon? A licensed agent can go over the application questions with you before you sign, and our guide on how long life insurance approval takes shows what happens next. Request a life insurance quote.

What happens after two years, and why replacing a policy restarts the clock

Once the contestability period ends, the policy generally becomes much harder for the insurer to challenge, apart from narrow exceptions such as unpaid premiums. That is one reason to think carefully before replacing an older policy. A brand-new policy comes with a brand-new two-year window.

The same idea applies to a policy that lapses and is reinstated. Reinstatement usually involves new health questions, and statements on that reinstatement application can be reviewed too. Paying premiums on time keeps you from reopening those questions.

How to protect your family's payout

  1. Answer every question fully, even when the answer feels small or embarrassing.
  2. When in doubt, disclose it. Let the underwriter decide whether it matters.
  3. Read the copy of your application that comes with your policy. It is usually attached to and part of the contract.
  4. Fix mistakes now. If you spot an error, contact your agent or the insurer to correct it in writing while you can explain it yourself.
  5. Report changes before delivery when asked. If your health changes between applying and receiving the policy, read your delivery paperwork, since some insurers ask about this before the policy takes effect.
  6. Tell your beneficiaries where the policy is. A family that can find the policy and the application can respond quickly if the insurer asks questions.

If you are still deciding on coverage, start with how much life insurance you need and the four main types of life insurance, then see our life insurance page for coverage in Wisconsin, Arizona and Colorado.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long is the life insurance contestability period?

It is usually two years from the date the policy is issued. Wisconsin's statute, for example, generally bars contesting an individual life policy after two years in force, with exceptions such as unpaid premiums.

Can a life insurance claim be denied for something left off the application?

Yes, if the claim comes in during the contestability period and the missing detail was material. The insurer may adjust the benefit or rescind the policy and refund premiums, which is why complete answers matter.

Does an honest mistake mean my family gets nothing?

Not automatically. Insurers look at whether the detail would have changed their decision, and outcomes range from paying in full to adjusting the benefit to rescinding the policy.

Do I need to tell my insurer about health changes after the policy is issued?

Generally no. Approval and pricing are based on the information when you applied, though some insurers ask about changes between the application and delivery of the policy.

Does the two-year clock restart if I replace my policy?

Yes. A new policy starts its own contestability period, which is worth weighing before you replace coverage you already have.

Request your life insurance quote

Email first. We only call if you ask us to.

Takes about 2 minutes.

If you tick the email box and don't finish, we may email you to help you finish this request.

Sending this form is a request to be contacted about insurance. A licensed insurance agent with Merit Protection Group will contact you. It is not an application and does not start or change any coverage.

  • Your information is encrypted and sent securely.

Your details are never sold or shared for marketing. See our privacy policy.

Go over your application with a licensed agent

Merit Protection Group is an independent insurance agency in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin, licensed in Wisconsin, Arizona and Colorado. We are an agency, not an insurer. A licensed agent can walk through the application questions with you and compare options from several insurers. Call (877) 908-5937 or request a quote online.