Why the Rules of Thumb Only Get You Partway
Which is why two families with identical incomes can need wildly different amounts.
"Ten times your income." Quick and not unreasonable as a first pass. But it treats a 32-year-old with a new mortgage and two toddlers the same as a 56-year-old whose house is paid off and whose children have graduated. Those two people need very different policies. It also ignores everything the household already has — savings, an existing policy, a working spouse.
The DIME method — Debt, Income, Mortgage, Education — is better because it asks what the money is actually for. Its weakness is double counting: your mortgage is also a debt, and it's easy to add it twice and arrive at a number larger than you need.
Both are starting points. Neither is an answer. The useful version is a subtraction problem.
Step 1: What Would Your Household Lose?
Go through these honestly, with actual numbers rather than estimates where you can:
- Income replacement. Your take-home pay, times the number of years your household would genuinely need it. Not an arbitrary multiple — think about when the youngest child finishes school, or when a spouse could realistically support the household alone.
- The mortgage. The remaining balance, if the goal is for your family to stay in the house without that payment.
- Other debts. Car loans, credit cards, personal loans, any business debt you've personally guaranteed.
- Education. What you intend to contribute, not the full sticker price of a private university unless that's genuinely the plan.
- Final expenses. A funeral, medical bills, and the administrative costs of settling an estate.
- The services you provide. More on this below — it's the line most households leave out entirely.
Step 2: The Coverage Most Households Forget
Here's the gap that shows up again and again: a household insures the paycheck and not the labor.
If a stay-at-home parent dies, no income disappears. But childcare, after-school care, meal preparation, transportation, and household management all suddenly have to be purchased or absorbed by a surviving parent who is also grieving and also working.
Price it out for your own situation. Full-time childcare for two young children in the Milwaukee area is not a small line item, and it runs for years. A household that insures one spouse for $500,000 and the other for nothing has made an assumption it probably hasn't examined.
The same logic applies in reverse to a household where one person handles elder care for a parent, or manages a family business's books. Ask what would have to be hired out, and for how long.
Step 3: Subtract What Already Exists
This is where the number usually comes down, sometimes substantially.
Social Security survivors benefits
Most people don't count these, and for a household with children they can be significant.
If you've worked and paid Social Security taxes, your survivors may be eligible. Based on the Social Security Administration's rules:
- Children who are unmarried and age 17 or younger, or 18 to 19 and still in high school (grade 12 or below) full time, or any age if a disability began at 21 or younger. Children generally receive 75% of the parent's benefit.
- A surviving spouse caring for the deceased's child who is under 16 or disabled may be eligible regardless of their own age or how long the marriage lasted.
- A surviving spouse at age 60 or older, or 50 to 59 with a disability, generally after at least nine months of marriage. Benefits start at 71.5% and rise to as much as 100% at full retirement age for survivors.
- Ex-spouses may qualify if the marriage lasted at least ten years.
There's a cap on total family benefits, so payments may be reduced to stay under it. There's also a one-time death payment of $255, which is worth knowing exists and not worth planning around.
Get your actual number rather than guessing. You can call the Social Security Administration at 1-800-772-1213 for an estimate. For a family with young children, this can represent several years of meaningful monthly support, and it directly reduces how much insurance you need to buy.
Existing coverage and assets
- Savings and investments your family could actually access
- Any individual policy you already own
- A working spouse's income, at a realistic level
- Employer group coverage — with an important caveat
Why employer coverage shouldn't count fully
Group life through work is a real benefit and worth having. It's also not yours.
It ends when the job ends. It's often one or two times salary, which is rarely enough on its own. And the moment you'd most want it to still be there — a layoff, a health event that costs you the job — is exactly when it disappears.
Count it, but treat it as a supplement rather than a foundation. The policy you own and control is the one that's there regardless of what happens to your employment.
Step 4: Insure the Gap
What's left after the subtraction is your number. The arithmetic matters far more than any typical range, because a range is just other people's situations.
Our life insurance calculator walks through this in about a minute and gives you a coverage range to start from.
How Much Do You Need If You're Single, Married or Covered at Work?
The subtraction works the same way for everyone. What changes is which lines carry weight.
If you're single with no one depending on your income
Your number is often small: final expenses, plus any debt someone else would be left holding, like a co-signed student loan or a mortgage you share. Some single people buy more anyway because they expect to marry or have children, and coverage bought while young and healthy usually costs less than coverage bought later.
For your spouse or partner
Run the numbers for each of you separately. The higher earner usually needs more, but a spouse who earns less, or nothing, still needs coverage if the household would have to pay for childcare, cooking, driving and everything else they handle now.
If you have life insurance through work
Many employers include basic coverage of about one year's salary and let you buy supplemental coverage on top. Supplemental coverage is handy as a top-up, but it usually ends or changes when you leave the job, and its price often climbs with each age band. Our guide on whether life insurance through work is enough walks through what to check.
How Long Matters As Much As How Much
The amount and the term are the same decision, and separating them is how people end up underinsured at exactly the wrong moment.
Choose the term based on when your household stops depending on you financially — the year the youngest child finishes school, the year the mortgage is paid, the year a spouse's retirement accounts can carry things alone. A 10-year term costs less each month, but if your children are 4 and 6, it expires right when you'd still want it in force.
The technique worth knowing about: laddering
Your need isn't flat. It's highest when the mortgage is large and the children are small, and it declines steadily from there.
Rather than buying one large policy for 30 years, some people buy two or three policies of different lengths. For example, a 10-year policy and a 30-year policy layered together — large coverage during the highest-need years, with the shorter policy expiring once that need has passed.
The result is coverage that follows the actual shape of your obligation, often at lower total cost than one large long policy. Ask for it to be quoted both ways and compare.
The Mistake That Costs More Than Being Underinsured
Buying a policy you can't sustain.
A $1,500,000 policy that lapses in year four because the premium became unmanageable protects nobody. A $500,000 policy in force for thirty years protects a family.
If the "right" number produces a premium that strains your budget, the answer isn't to buy it anyway and hope. It's to buy what you can comfortably maintain, and increase it when your situation improves — some term policies include a rider or conversion option that helps, and otherwise new coverage means a new application. Coverage that stays in force beats coverage that's theoretically perfect.
And this is also why the type of policy follows the amount rather than leading it. For a household that needs substantial coverage on a limited budget, term is what makes the number achievable. Our guide to the four main types of life insurance covers when permanent coverage makes sense instead.
Revisit It When Life Changes
The number isn't permanent. Recalculate when you:
- Have a child, or adopt one
- Buy a house or refinance
- Change jobs — especially if group coverage changes
- Start a business or take on a personal guarantee
- Pay off the mortgage
- Divorce, remarry, or become responsible for a parent
Most people buy once and never look again. A ten-minute review every few years is how coverage stays matched to the life it's protecting.
Put the Rest of Your Plan in Writing
Life insurance is money for the people you leave behind, and your beneficiary form decides who gets it. A will is commonly used for the rest: who gets the other things you own, and who you want to raise young children.
If making a will has been on your list, EZ Will and Trust is an online estate-planning service. It walks you through a will or a living trust at home, at your own pace, and you make every choice yourself.
Merit Protection Group may earn a commission if you buy through this link. We are an insurance agency, not a law firm, and this is general information, not legal advice. For questions about your own situation, talk with an attorney licensed in your state.
Run the Numbers With Someone
Merit Protection Group is an independent insurance agency in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. We'll walk through the arithmetic with you — what your household would lose, what it already has, and what's genuinely left to cover — and compare how different carriers price that amount. Our state guides cover what changes where you live: Wisconsin life insurance, Arizona term life insurance and Colorado life insurance.
If the answer is less coverage than you expected, that's what we'll tell you.
Questions about your specific Social Security benefits belong with the SSA, and tax questions belong with a CPA. We'll point you there rather than guessing.
Try the coverage calculator, request a quote, or contact us with questions. No pressure, and no obligation.
