Merit Protection Group

Life insurance

Can I Withdraw Cash Value From My Life Insurance Policy?

Yes — if you have a permanent policy that has built up cash value. You generally have three ways to reach it: a withdrawal, a policy loan, or surrendering the policy entirely. Each one gives you money today and takes something away permanently.

Two young children sharing a swing in a sunny backyard

First: Does Your Policy Even Have Cash Value?

If you have term life insurance, there's nothing to withdraw. Term policies have no cash value, which is exactly why they cost so much less.

The question most people are actually asking is what will this cost me? That answer is more complicated than the sales material suggests, and it's worth understanding before you call the insurance company.

Term life insurance: no cash value. Ever. It's pure protection for a set number of years.

Whole, universal, indexed universal, and variable life: these build cash value, but slowly at first. In the early years, a large share of each premium goes to the cost of insurance, policy expenses, and the commission paid on the sale. It's common for a policy to have very little accessible value in its first several years, and for people to be genuinely surprised by that.

Our guide to the four main types of life insurance explains how each one accumulates value differently.

The fastest way to find out what you actually have: look at your most recent annual statement, or call the carrier and ask for the current cash surrender value — not the cash value. Those are two different numbers, and the difference is surrender charges.

The Three Ways to Get at It

1. A withdrawal (sometimes called a partial surrender)

You take money out and don't pay it back.

What it costs: your death benefit is permanently reduced, usually by at least the amount withdrawn and sometimes by more. Surrender charges may apply. And the money you take out stops growing.

There's no interest and nothing to repay, which makes it feel like the simplest option. It's also the most permanent.

2. A policy loan

You borrow against the cash value. The insurer is lending you money and holding your policy as collateral — your cash value stays in the policy.

What it costs: interest accrues, and unpaid interest typically gets added to the loan balance. You're not required to repay on a schedule, which sounds generous and is the source of most of the trouble this option causes.

If you die with a loan outstanding, your beneficiaries receive the death benefit minus the loan balance. A $250,000 policy with a $60,000 loan pays $190,000.

3. Surrendering the policy

You cancel the policy and take the cash surrender value — the cash value minus any surrender charges and any outstanding loan.

What it costs: everything. The coverage ends. And replacing it later means being older and, in many cases, less healthy than when you bought it. If your health has changed since you were underwritten, that coverage may not be replaceable at any price.

What It Actually Costs You

Three costs, and only the first one is obvious.

The death benefit shrinks. This is the one people understand but discount, because it's a cost paid by someone else at a time they'd rather not think about. If the reason you bought the policy still exists, this is the real price.

Surrender charges. Most permanent policies carry them for ten to fifteen years, declining over time. Taking money out in year six can cost meaningfully more than taking the same amount in year twelve.

The compounding stops on whatever leaves. Cash value in a permanent policy is slow to build precisely because of the early-year costs — and that means the value you've accumulated represents years of those costs already absorbed. Pulling it out is giving up the part you already paid for.

The Tax Rules, in Plain Terms

This section is general information, not tax advice. Run your specific numbers past a CPA before you take money out, because the amounts involved are often large enough that a mistake is expensive.

For a normal (non-MEC) policy: withdrawals come out of your basis first. Your basis is generally the total premiums you've paid in. Money you take out up to that amount is usually not taxed, because it's your own money coming back. Amounts above your basis are generally taxed as ordinary income.

Policy loans are generally not taxable while the policy stays in force. This is why loans get promoted so heavily as a way to access money "income-tax-free." That phrase is doing a lot of work, and the next section explains why.

Surrender: anything you receive above your basis is generally taxed as ordinary income.

If your policy is a modified endowment contract, the rules are worse

A policy becomes a modified endowment contract (MEC) when too much premium goes in too quickly in the early years — it fails what the tax code calls the seven-pay test. This often happens to policies that were deliberately overfunded to build cash value faster.

For a MEC:

  • Distributions come out gain first, not basis first — so the taxable portion comes off the top
  • Loans are treated as distributions, so the income-tax-free borrowing advantage disappears
  • A 10% penalty may apply to the taxable portion before age 59½
  • The designation is permanent. Once a policy is a MEC, it stays one

Ask your carrier directly whether your policy is a MEC before you take anything out. It's a yes-or-no question they can answer in one phone call, and the answer changes the math substantially.

The Trap Worth Understanding Before You Borrow

This is the part that gets left out, and it has ended badly for a lot of people.

Say you borrow against your policy over several years. You don't repay it, because nothing requires you to. Interest accrues and gets added to the balance. The loan grows. Eventually the loan balance approaches the cash value, and there isn't enough left to keep the policy in force.

The policy lapses. And at that moment, the forgiven loan is treated as money you received.

The Tax Court addressed this in Atwood v. Commissioner, holding that when a policy is disposed of through surrender or lapse, the release of the outstanding loan is treated as the equivalent of a cash distribution. The taxable amount is the loan balance above your basis.

So the outcome is this: your coverage is gone, you receive no money, and you may owe income tax on a loan you spent years ago. In McGowen v. Commissioner, the insurer issued a 1099 reporting over $500,000 of income on exactly this kind of termination, and the courts upheld it.

Policy loans aren't inherently bad. But "income-tax-free" only holds as long as the policy stays in force, and a loan left to compound quietly for twenty years is how policies stop staying in force.

If you have an outstanding loan, request an in-force illustration from your carrier at least once a year and look at how long the policy is projected to last at current rates. That single document is the early warning system.

Before You Take Money Out, Ask For This

Call the carrier and request an in-force illustration showing the policy's projected values after the specific amount you're considering taking.

Most people don't know they can ask for this. Carriers generally provide one on request, and it answers the questions that actually matter:

  • What will the death benefit be afterward?
  • How long will the policy stay in force at current crediting rates?
  • What happens if rates come in lower than projected?
  • What surrender charges apply right now, and when do they end?
  • Is the policy a MEC?

Ask for the version run at the guaranteed rate as well as the current one. If the policy survives on the guaranteed column after your withdrawal, that's a good sign. If it only works on the optimistic column, you're taking on more risk than the number suggests.

Things Worth Checking Before You Withdraw

Depending on why you need the money, your policy may already do something that costs you less.

An accelerated death benefit rider. Many policies let you access part of the death benefit early if you're terminally or chronically ill. If the need is medical, check this first — it's often already included in the policy.

Reducing the face amount. Lowering your coverage lowers the cost of insurance, which can reduce or eliminate the premium. If your coverage need has genuinely shrunk — the mortgage is paid, the children are grown — this keeps a policy in force instead of ending it.

Reduced paid-up. Many whole life policies let you convert to a smaller death benefit with no further premiums. You keep permanent coverage and stop paying.

Dividends. If you have participating whole life and dividends are buying additional insurance, redirecting them to cash or to offset premiums makes money available without touching the cash value itself.

None of these are right for everyone. The point is that "withdraw or surrender" isn't the whole menu, and the alternatives rarely come up unless someone asks.

Have Someone Read the Policy With You

Merit Protection Group is an independent insurance agency in Wauwatosa, Wisconsin. If you're thinking about taking money out of a policy, we're glad to go through the statement and the in-force illustration with you and explain what each option would actually do — including when the honest answer is to leave the policy alone.

We don't give tax or legal advice. Tax questions belong with a CPA, and we'll tell you plainly where that line is rather than guessing at it.

Contact us, read about how life insurance fits alongside retirement savings, or explore our life insurance options. No pressure, and no obligation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I withdraw cash value from my life insurance policy?

Yes, if you have a permanent policy with accumulated cash value. You can take a withdrawal, borrow against it with a policy loan, or surrender the policy for its cash surrender value. Term life insurance has no cash value to withdraw.

Can you withdraw dividends from a whole life policy?

With participating whole life, dividends can usually be taken as cash, used to lower your premium, left with the insurer to earn interest or used to buy extra coverage. Dividends aren't guaranteed, and cash dividends are generally not taxed until what you've received is more than the premiums you've paid.

Is withdrawing cash value from life insurance taxable?

For a standard policy, withdrawals up to the total premiums you've paid are generally not taxed, and amounts above that are generally taxed as ordinary income. Modified endowment contracts are taxed differently and less favorably. Confirm your situation with a CPA before withdrawing.

Does a withdrawal reduce my death benefit?

Yes. A withdrawal permanently reduces the death benefit, typically by at least the amount withdrawn. An unpaid policy loan also reduces what your beneficiaries receive, by the outstanding balance plus accrued interest.

What's the difference between a policy loan and a withdrawal?

A withdrawal permanently removes money and reduces the death benefit. A loan borrows against the cash value with interest accruing, and your beneficiaries receive the death benefit minus any unpaid balance. Loans are generally not taxable while the policy remains in force.

What happens if my policy lapses while I have a loan?

The outstanding loan is generally treated as money you received, and any amount above your cost basis is generally taxable as income. Your coverage ends, you receive no cash, and a tax bill can still result. Request an in-force illustration annually if you have a loan outstanding, and ask a CPA how the tax rules apply to you.

Request your life insurance quote

Email first. We only call if you ask us to.

Takes about 2 minutes.

If you tick the email box and don't finish, we may email you to help you finish this request.

Sending this form is a request to be contacted about insurance. A licensed insurance agent with Merit Protection Group will contact you. It is not an application and does not start or change any coverage.

  • Your information is encrypted and sent securely.

Your details are never sold or shared for marketing. See our privacy policy.